DARK MATTER OF ECONOMICS

Consumption Theory and Value: The Dark Matter of Economics

Getty Images
Adam Smith telling us the sole end and purpose.

‘The Sole End And Purpose’ - A Missing Focus

Consumption is given the very highest place in economics by Adam Smith - “consumption is the sole end and purpose of all production” - but we are about to see the study of consumption in economics is just honored in the breach.

There’s some pragmatism and even humility here. Practically, it’s immensely complex to ask and answer what people need and want, and how they are or are not satisfied, as a result of the goods and services they buy. So it’s pragmatic to accept that, if they make those purchases willingly, they are both satisfying and revealing preferences that would otherwise be hard to probe.

And in the larger historical context of economics - The Enlightenment, in which individuals and their autonomy came to be prized above all - it seems right, intellectually and politically humble even, to theorize the expression of those preferences in ways that don’t imply a moral or theoretical high ground of ‘knowing better’ what people should want or do.

But it’s also otherwise mysterious that it is so poorly examined, in part because of the enormity of the landscape of phenomena covered under the heading of consumption, and in part because of the vastness of the impacts of those phenomena. It’s no exaggeration to say large pieces of theoretical structure, even just systematic investigation, are missing.

Simply put, what the central matter of what matters about matter - where material value comes from and where it goes to, what the economy is actually doing and how and why - is somehow, marvelously, miraculously, absent. The ‘sole end and purpose’ of economics is largely underexamined.

It’s as if the economic analysis system were like a lazy physics: it knows that a profound dark matter exists in the economic universe - consumption, in a black box of opaque preferences that draws everything to it - sole end and purpose, universal economic gravity. But this economic physics, while knowing this is, unable or unwilling to make this dark matter a principal primary research challenge.

Impoverished Definitions - Social Science Misses The Mark

At the most basic level, economics as a profession doesn’t define consumption in a definitive or systematic way. There are only really two native ways for economics to define consumption:

  • expenditure in general, roughly macroeconomic at the personal level, where the focus is on balance of spending across a range of options and timescales; and
  • specific acts of expenditure, roughly microeconomic at the personal level, where the focus is on what kinds of preferences are being expressed and satisfied, ie the specific interface of consumers with specific producers and products.

Beyond this, related disciplines such as the social, psychological, and political sciences take over to explore themes such as the:

  • sociopsychological motivations and reward patterns at the individual level - what makes people buy what they buy and how does it make them feel; deeper than economics
  • cultural contexts of consumption - how does consumption happen in practice in society, what are transpersonal motivations and implications of economics; broader than economics
  • organizational aspects of consumption - how does consumption practically work as a sociotechnical phenomenon; more historical and political than economics.

Together with economics this package of disciplines and research themes , self-consciously, identifies as consumption studies domain. But these investigations are unable to surface let alone answer some of the most obvious questions. The mystery of the unexamined domain of consumption is surprisingly intact.

These consumption studies all practically accept that value in consumption is derived from consumer preference and preference satisfaction. But there must be - there is - more science in the value of goods than ‘people like them’. And there must be more to consumption than more or less close focus on the motivations and acts associated with purchasing. What about the dynamics of consumption that just aren’t about shopping, and its motivations and meanings? What about consumption as the study of materialized value?

For example: just because it is not true that all low entropy materials in the world are valuable to humans - surely does not mean that the astonishing correlation between low entropy phenomena and economic value is a worthless red-herring? Indeed, we know that food is valuable primarily because of its low entropy stores: we’ll buy and eat food we don’t like when we are starving.

And we often know why, objectively, some products are better than others - we have words for it: faster, sharper, smaller, more durable, more repairable; in distinction to more descriptions of whether they are preferential in personal and subjective ways. In fact, in many maybe most cases, when you ask people why they like what they buy, they can give you actual reasons - which hints at some kind of objective data, even if an unreliable sort in a small sample.

The Lessons of Production Theory - Be Specific

There’s a suggestive and revelatory irony here. Even if economics as a whole, out of pragmatism or humility, is able to leave consumer preferences, let alone any theory of value, as implicit facts only ever ‘revealed in purchase’ but not indicative of any deeper reality, producers cannot do so. This is because they need guidance as to what to ‘objectively produce’: the market is not a blind sequence of trial and error exercises which over time land on whatever consumers like. It is willed experiment where all products on offer are, on the supply side at least, expressions of decisions and intentions, not amorphous preferences.

This imbalance between production and consumption, operationally, culturally and theoretically is in fact a rich source of questions and insights about what is missing and what might be supplied to the future of consumption studies. To highlight this, let’s explore the phenomenological landscape of consumption, with some due reference to the corollary in production.

In the theory of economics - in fact a large part of the history and theory of economics is demonstrating that - good and services are not simply supplied to society from thin air: certain kinds of people and organizations have to do certain kinds of things. Owners, firms, markets, contracts, prices, manufacture, distribution are all required roles and processes on the supply side of the economy. An intricate solar system of relations, inputs, outputs, incentives, optimizations, iterations, progress.

But on the consumption side of the economy, there are so few such elements: individual people, goods and services. That’s pretty much it. How is this not a gaping theoretical and practical gap? Where is the technical and analytical machinery? Where is the expectation of optimization?

There are perfectly good reasons to believe it should be there. Why and how so much sophistication appears on the production side of economic theory is that it is, according to the textbooks, seeking to solve the ‘allocation problem’ of economically advanced societies: society needs to work out how best to allocate scarce resources to preferred outcomes, and so ends up needing a theory of firms, contracts, prices, production.

Fair enough. But if that allocation problem leads to super-refined institutional and technical processes for suitable production, why is consumption such an analytical dead end? How come the allocation problem - truly understanding it, optimizing it, resolving it - isn’t taken clearly on the demand side of the economy, where it is just as much, perhaps even more, at stake? Can it really be true, on reflection, that ‘I bought it because I wanted it’ is the pearl in the oyster of economics, the ultimate resolution of the allocation problem?

At the very least, to allow so smacks of a paucity of intellectual ambition. Even if we allow that the social and political science packaging of economic consumption remedies some of this lack of analytic and theoretic texture - supplying expanded institutional and cultural contexts, richer motivations, timelines, implications; and avoiding the heavy hand of implied dogmatics about what might be suitable according to some exogenous criteria - it is not nearly enough to map the terrain of consumption phenomena that are obviously in play.

Consumption, as a set of materialization practices - rather than just the conventional transaction, purchase, ownership dynamics - seems almost like terra incognita, an uninvestigated flora and fauna of ideas and practices that are yet all around us. Contrast this with the veritable botany and zoology of production theory: where every trace of money, trade, supply, logistics, resources, labour, output, productivity, and all the colors of the productive phenomenology are parsed, probed, illuminated for deeper implications and potential.

Or perhaps consumption is more like dark matter: the greatest source of substance and thus gravity in the universe, but poorly unobserved and thus dimly understood. The engine of what is, but comparatively absent from the conversation.

The Seed of Definition - A New Consumption Function

More specifically, an example of the definition rigour in the economics is the so-called production function. Here we see the conceptual sophistication, the botanical rigor, of the production side of economic theory laid out: land and resources, labour, capital in the form of money and machinery, are theorized and combined to propose how, across competing firms, goods are variously produced that are then tested for price/value optima in a competitive market. This is indeed the constitutive mechanism for ‘how production gets done properly’, how allocation problems are solved: the rigor and fine-resolution is needed to solve the problem. And it feeds back on itself: the details and structure of the production function guide investigation, research, innovation, policy.

But where is the equivalent on the demand side of the economy? Why is there no consumption function of an equivalent sort - a constitutive mechanism for how consumption delivers utility outcomes, a kind of ‘transformation consumption function’, a model and measure to match the production function? The ‘consumption function’ that does exist - a simple measure of how spending rises and falls - is nothing of the sort.

The allocation problem - the need to ensure best use of scarce resources - should apply here no less than in production, surely. No stone should be left unturned, least of all if consumption is the ‘sole end and purpose’ of all this.

No-one should allow ‘well it’s how I felt when I bought it’ to be a sufficient (at least theoretical) justification for purchases, any more than ‘well it’s how I felt when I made it’ would be considered a credible alternative to a production function on the supply side of the economy.

A transformation consumption function might tell us a variety of critical but currently vaguely defined things. These include why, for example, a consumer might (with notes on what theory about this might elaborate and formalize):

  • prefer a product vs service in a specific case - product vs service definitions, or axis of definition
  • choose to buy not borrow from friends or colleagues - ownership vs sharing
  • consumer wanted new vs second hand - new vs second hand, and destruction of value
  • sticks with a brand vs changing brand - feature or function set, or experiential difference, per equivalent brand
  • either learns or doesn’t learn more effective even expert use of a product - skill-in-use and knowledge-in-use as part of consumption actions

and countless other fully factual implications of consumption that are orthogonal to, say, why they like the product in the first place, or how much they like it, or why or how they chose to buy. These aspects of consumption, currently undefined or poorly defined, but perhaps something that might attach to a transformation consumption function, are not about the preference satisfaction per se, but about the transformation dynamics and effectiveness of the operational consumption activities.

So we may say this, as a reflection on the potential of a transformation consumption function, to invite the sophistication of the (transformation-oriented) production function: even if we accepted that consumption activity is a black box in respect of preferences, let alone actual utility - preferences are hidden inside and only partly revealed through purchase signal, and utility is taken for granted - that black box itself ... has some detectable shape!

The goal then is to dimension and examine the box properly, even without trying to get inside. This is just putting consumption on par with the production: no-one claims studying production phenomenologically through the production function is breaching the black box of consumer preference, or denying the invisible hand. It’s just making visible what is there, with no judgement or agenda.

Let’s Science - The Taxonomy of The Phenomenology of Consumption

A starting point to the larger potential of consumption studies would indeed probably then be a fuller phenomenological review and tentative taxonomy of consumption experiences - before any truly theoretical framing. Even the simplest surface pass here is immensely rich and instructive: consumption, beyond the mere act of buying something - let’s call this the transaction - encompasses actions intended to ‘satisfy preferences’ in such diverse dimensions:

  • eating an apple
  • driving a car
  • wearing clothes
  • watching television
  • collecting old coins
  • skydiving
  • cooking food for friends

It’s no use saying that this phenomenal spread is too wide to be analytically husbanded - no-one says farming and computer chip manufacture and singing opera are too distant from each other to be handled by the same overarching production theories.

On further inspection, however, it’s clear quite how much foundational work is really required to even offer up a taxonomy that is stable. To take two examples indicative of the scale and omnipresence of the challenge:

  • are products and services precisely differentiated in economics?
  • is even production differentiated from consumption with analytic certainty?

To offer a starting point that illustrates how necessary this work is, we will note it’s superficially easy to separate products and services, even to treat this as natural or perhaps sufficient ontology of consumption types: products are things and services are experiences. But on inspection, this boundary collapses entirely as strange as that might seem.

What’s the difference between a long-term car lease, and a car purchase with 100% financing? Is the consumption experience of a television something about the object - the physical product - or about the content flowing through it to your eyes and ears - which feels like a service? Economics and accounting start using technical terms like stocks and flows when pressed on this point - goods are ‘stocks’ and services are ‘flows’. But flows of what? It’s tautologous to say services are flows of ... services?

Ok, but if products and services have a blurred boundary, surely production and consumption don’t? That which is produced is that which gets consumed - how could these possibly overlap? They even seem to be temporally not just conceptually distinct: consumption must happen after production, surely? This is surely a natural insight and maps to a lot of production and consumption: apples are harvested (produced), and then apples are eaten (consumed); movie screenings are shown (produced), and then movie screenings are seen (consumed).

But again, this is just the beginning of the story. When one is making food for others in the kitchen - with equipment and ingredients one has bought - is this consumption or production of meals? When one is driving to work, in particular driving a friend to work, is this consumption of the car as a good (or a service), or is it production of rides?

These two mini-investigations start to show how the lack of definition and sophistication in the area of consumption theory isn’t just a problem for theory: they are problems for practice of good economic policy, good business, good society. This should not be surprising: what did we think the implications of the ‘sole end and purpose’ economics would be? The stakes of this are huge, and concrete, not just speculative.

Specifically, on these two points: economies look very different, for example, if the emphasis is on service-based production and consumption, vs product: and this is exactly what some economists and social-environmental theorists propose. And economics - in fact not just economics but housing, cities, jobs, taxes, leisure - would look very different if consumption was formally viewed not as a terminal dead-end of economic activity, but as itself a generative, production-enabling act, if not actually production itself in many cases.

If some of the ‘science’ of economics is missing - what consumption really is - then likewise the engineering corollary is missing - what we would do with consumption if we understood it better.

Phenomenology of Value - AWOL also

If economics is cautious about addressing utility directly - the experience of value, and notion of personal and collective wellbeing - it’s even more resistant to talk value. And again, this is highly pragmatic. Value is even more slippery and liable to penalize investigation than utility. Economics roughly says:if utility is what individuals want and get in a functioning market economy, value is what society wants and gets in a functioning market economy.

But once again, looking at this through a consumption and production lens is instructive. For a start, production-side economics is much less cagey about talking about value than it might seem.

There’s surely something simple and practical about how production treats resources of whatever sort: supply chain, inventory, assets, etc. We know these are ‘valuable’, they are essentially ‘valuable by definition’ not by, say, price. As production proceeds, all the valuable pieces of the production economy are then necessarily present and correct, and accounted for carefully: sufficiently carefully that the actual value added to them, separately and together, as one lump of iron becomes one ton of steel, and blocks of steel, glass, rubber become cars, is the whole of both company and national accounts.

In fact, while it is denominated in money, rather than something more concrete, the essence of GDP - national accounts - is to assess not merely how much was bought by end-consumers in the economy, but how much was bought by producers and in particular, how much value was added during the production process. Defining and measuring value-added might not amount to defining what value is, but it’s clearly a step towards treating value as a concrete thing.

But once again, what happens to all this confidence and concreteness, and confidence-in-concreteness, on the demand side of the economy? If we know how much value has been added, and in principle where and when and to some extent how or at least by whom, why can’t we or at least don’t we ask: where does the value go in consumption?

Once material resources make their way into the consumption side of the economy, not just the value of economically-framed resources, but the concepts used to track it, seems to break down entirely.

No-one talks about an ‘inventory’ of shirts in the closet, or the ‘supply chain’ of resources required for evening meal. And while some household assets are treated as economic items - house prices appreciate, and car values depreciate - such framing and specificity is never widely applied to all goods, let alone services. Practically, when goods and services are let loose on the world, ready for consumers, their value basically crashes, almost without regard to whether any actual consumption activity is taking place at all on them.

So, where does this value go? Why this matters is we are talking about ... all the economic activity ever undertaken, which directly or indirectly contributes to the value that is addressed in pricing, and putatively experienced in consumption. How come there’s no through-accounting, no value-depletion ‘national accounts’ in the same way there are value-addition national accounts in the form of GDP?

Why are we so obsessed with tracking the flow of scarce resources - so we can allocate it with optimal efficiency and beat that pernicious allocation problem, on the supply side of the economy while we do nothing comparable on the demand side. On the demand side of economic thinking, we can’t and don’t seek to explain, at least to ourselves in our own lives and plans, let alone theoretically, where all the scarce value embodied in these scarce goods based on scarce resources ends up, and if that’s a good thing or if something else better might be done under the heading of consumption. This is the same question-frame ultimately as, what is the operational phenomenology of consumption, just applied at the level of value; what is the value phenomenology of consumption, which we justify on very reasonable basis that ‘production does it better’, on both levels.

Towards a Science and Engineering of Consumption

In so far as consumption theory is critiqued at all, it is a target for elaboration by the social scientists and related fields. It’s almost as if, and rightly so, the social sciences and humanities want to reclaim some of their own - the human experience of economics, the goal of the economy, from the depredations of economics where everything is treated as if some sub-field of physics, without humanity, and the brutality of commerce, where selling is winning is right, and science is lost and who cares.

But in this emphasis is missed the opportunity, not to pack consumption with inappropriate moral or psychological framings and presumption, but rather the opposite, to let the black box of preference to stay unopened, even unopenable, but to measure the box itself, ie how preferences are enacted as a series of physical, phenomenal acts.

Buying a clock-radio may be be an act of preference, but the fact that, in the act of having and using a clock-radio, one by definition does not have both a clock AND a radio is a fact, not itself a preference. Using a ride-share instead of owning and having a car may be an act of preference, but the fact that, once set up, ride-sharing infrastructure requires less space for parking and offers more space for housing and nature and amenities, for no less quantity or even quality of miles travelled necessarily, is a fact, not itself a preference.

And this terrain of facts is, I believe, the dark matter on the demand side of the economy that has been poorly theorized, and underrepresented in science, study, practice of economics, let alone downstream in policy, business, society, urban fabric, culture, aspiration.

On the operational level, we can ask, where is even the taxonomy let alone theory of material practices that would begin to fill out this gap in the theoretical landscape. This is surely a contribution to the ‘humanity-resources’ problem - the allocation problem described more generally - that motivates microeconomics theoretically.

On the strategic level, but very much still within the realms of practicability - at least by the criterion of ‘production theory does it’ - we can ask, where does ‘value go’ on the demand side of the economy, even if we rightly are cautious about asking what value is. This is surely a contribution not just to a ‘matter-value’ problem - how value ‘gets into and out of matter’, sometimes touched on in deep economic investigations - but also is critical to concrete macroeconomic accounting.

If consumption is the ‘sole end and purpose’ of economics, it deserves a lot more considered attention.