DIRNDL ON A RHINO

Notes on John Elkington's article about Ethical Altruism and what it can offer sustainability, or not, and what it can learn in return.

https://sandcountyfoundation.org, https://search.library.wisc.edu/digital/AEJ4WOPT7ND4LY8G
Scientist not thinkfluencer, Aldo Leopold. Photo: Charles Bradley

A note on this post by eco-business hero John Elkington. Reflections on EA, tech and sustainability


This is pretty interesting -and I think it's very thoughtful and extremely prescient, discriminating and well-read to bring this to the sustainability debate.

The missing pieces however seem to me these:

1 EA is tech

Technology and tech money has always been the driving force of EA, with some perfume added by pliant and ephemeral academics/thinkfluencers (McAskill, Bostrom). When you say EA should take systems more seriously, you mean that tech and tech money should take systems more seriously. EA is just a Twitter dirndl on the tech rhino.

And this opens the door to the real questions: tech is not bad because it is tech, or even saturated in money. It is bad because it has become corporatist and worse.

Addressing EA and their low regard for systems and institution is a weak-kneed and disposable - but neat - way of saying: simplistic (don't be evil) and corporatist (must get my regulated 2TN IPO bag to help society) concepts of social change don't work. Go big, tell tech to do systems.

Flirting in the dark with a curvy creature in a dirndl isn't going to herd any rhinos.

2 Sustainability is not yet tech

The lesson you, JE, you have taught sustainability is that commerce and enterprise is necessary for sustainability.

The lesson you keep fumbling, see above - if you get it all? - is that corporatism is not enterprise, and all thoughtful societies need to resolve this difference.

The lesson I think you don't get at all - but the report you just got should clarify for you - is that tech is the main vector of transformative change availalbe to society, if only - table stakes but a start - through using data properly at scale for public and enviro purposes (the gateway to benign AI). You, we, sustainability are 20 years behind the curve on this.

The crucial distinction is whether that tech facilitates enterprise or more corporatism. If we don't have that distinction clear, and/or can't parse it because dont' get the tech and how it really works (and how easy it is to decouple the good stuff from corporatism, and no not just by open source) - or worse have a demented presumption that all tech is class heavy-industrial harm - we wont' be able to deploy it for the good.

But I think we can and will - esp for city/infra stuff (see, again, your own survey headlines: tech + cities ftw). Your article is part of the techenaissance.

tl;dr sustainbility can/must learn commerce, but must also learn tech without feeding corporatism. EA stuff, again, is just the barndance before the marriage here.

3 EA is not science

Notable again is that EA got perfume and cred from low rent academics (see above), but it never became academia,let alone science.

The marriage of convenience is collapsing now, tech ppl don't need it - Anthropic talks the EA book without EA - and the academics aren't getting money, so won't provide the cred.

Under it, we note that nothing of substance remains. No books, papers, theories. The strongest claims by Bostrom are now passé, openly craven, or just weird. McAskill is having to justify himself in the Economist, because his work is now understood not to be research or philosophy.

Sustainability is nothing like this. It's built on literal and metaphoric tectonic layers of science. Earth sciences giving us climate, water, soil; biosciences giving us diversity and resilience; political sciences giving us governance mechanisms; economic science giving us, or trying to, market mechanisms. All of it providing data, discourse, polity.

Let's be clear that these are not alike. If you did a globscan thing of all the EA ppls, you'd get a bunch of bounced emails from ppl whose substack died last year, and whose tech adjacent money dried up. It's not based on science or scholarship, and it's not an epochal movement. In Silicon Valley you can see it dying in real time, and people are laughing openly (they did so privately before).

tl;dr Eliezer Yudkowsky is no Aldo Leopold or Rachel Carson, or John Elkington ftm.

4 EA is morality for stupid people

As they say, politics is showbiz for ugly people. I say: economics is science for stupid people. And: EA is ethics for lazy people.

Even 30 minutes worth of calm investigation of the writings of EA leaders - frankly and sincerely including the academics - gives the distinctive 'second year Oxford vibe': easily smart and confident enough to impress, often thoughtful and stylish enough to convince, and yet clearly not through or well-read or even grounded in actual insight or care to substantiate their own beliefs, let alone survive sustained contact with reality.

The emeritus founder of EA is Groucho Marx: "Those are my principles, and if you don't like them...well I have others.”

It's not accidental that rampant immorality and illegality surround EA: it's because it isn't trying to 'do' ethics in the old-fashioned sense of 'establishing ethical understanding and moral practices' - which led to millennia of discourse and anguish and political praxiology - it's trying to 'be right' with all the psychological vigour of rich people wondering what to do after the IPO/breakfast and, frankly, second year politics students at university who have nothing to fear but boredom. Strangely enough, 'post-breakfast ethics' turns out to be, well, whatever the nice-adjacent ppl with money seem to think is nice-enough.

Back to the beginning: just because a rich person or a corporation - and above all their blog-writing / paper-writing outiders who love having rich friends who are relaxed about money and somewhat liberal - says something, doesn't make it true, relevant, or durable.

Sustainability is to be the movement of the 21st century - necessarily for survival since neither this nor any century will be the era of Mars colonization movement - and has to adopt tech and tech money (and IMHO the genuinely liberal and good-hearted intentions that underpin this trend) in ways EA has failed to do.